Why a Waiver in Your EJS Can Cost You More Than the Estate Tax

I know of a family who decided to settle their late parent’s estate under the estate tax amnesty. They did everything they were supposed to do. They had an Extrajudicial Settlement of Estate drafted, all the heirs signed it, and they had it notarized. They published it in a newspaper as required. Then they went to the BIR to file.

They expected the amnesty to take care of the tax. Instead, they were told they still had a large amount to pay.

They couldn’t understand it. Wasn’t the whole point of the amnesty to spare them from that?

The problem was a single part of their EJS: the waiver.

In many families, not every heir wants to take a share. Some of the brothers and sisters agree that the property should go to just one of them, maybe the one who took care of the parents, or the one who still lives in the family home. So the EJS includes a waiver, where the other heirs give up their shares in favor of that sibling.

It seems like a family matter, and in a way it is. But in the eyes of the BIR, a waiver made in favor of a specific heir is a donation. The heirs who waived are treated as having given their shares away to the heir who received them. And donations are subject to donor’s tax, which is 6% of the value given away in excess of ₱250,000 in a year.

The estate tax amnesty only covers the estate tax. It doesn’t cover donor’s tax. So while the family was spared from paying the regular estate tax, the waiver in their EJS was assessed separately. Depending on the value of the property, that can easily turn out to be the bigger bill.

That’s what surprised this family, and I suspect many others have gone through the same thing.

A quick note on timing. The estate tax amnesty ended on June 14, 2025, and as of this writing it hasn’t been extended again. Estates settled now pay the regular estate tax. But the lesson about waivers hasn’t changed, because donor’s tax on a waiver is assessed whether or not there’s an amnesty.

A few things are worth knowing here.

Not every waiver is taxed the same way. A general renunciation, where an heir simply gives up his share without saying who it should go to, is generally not subject to donor’s tax. It’s the waiver made in favor of a particular heir that the BIR treats as a donation. The wording and the way the document is structured matter a great deal.

An uneven division can also count as a waiver. If the heirs divide the properties so that someone ends up with less than his rightful share, the BIR may treat the difference as having been given away, and tax it accordingly.

And if the heir who waived was paid for his share, it’s no longer a waiver or a donation at all. It may be treated as a sale, which carries its own taxes.

Waivers matter beyond taxes, too. A waiver an heir signed without really understanding it, or an heir who was left out of the EJS altogether, is one of the most common reasons a “settled” estate ends up in court years later. Under Rule 74 of the Rules of Court, an extrajudicial settlement doesn’t bind an heir who didn’t take part in it or wasn’t notified of it, and that heir can go to court to claim his share. Getting the document right, with everyone properly included, protects the family from that fight.

The lesson here is simple. Before you sign an EJS, especially one with a waiver, know what it will cost. The amnesty, or any tax relief for that matter, only covers what it says it covers. If your family has agreed that one heir should get more than the others, decide with your lawyer how that will be done before the document is drafted. It’s much easier to get it right at the start than to find out at the BIR window.

If your family is planning to settle an estate and you want to make sure there are no surprises, feel free to reach out and book a consultation.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Atty. Marc Bañares

Litigation lawyer focused on land, title and property disputes. Bañares Law, Parañaque.

Previous
Previous

Tenant Refuses to Receive Your Demand Letter? There’s a Way Around It