Why Seeing the Owner’s Duplicate Title Isn’t Enough When You’re Buying Property

I get this question a lot. A buyer finds a property they like, the seller shows them the owner’s duplicate copy of the title, and the buyer asks me, “Attorney, how do I know this title is real?”

It’s a fair question. With today’s technology, faking a document has become easier than ever. A scammer with a good printer and the right paper can produce a title that looks every bit as real as the genuine one. For buyers, that is a serious problem.

So how can you tell whether the owner’s duplicate shown to you is authentic?

The honest answer is that you can’t, at least not right there on the spot. There is no way to look at a duplicate title across the table and declare with certainty that it is genuine. Paper, seals, and signatures can all be copied.

What you can do is go to the Registry of Deeds where the property is registered and request a Certified True Copy (CTC) of the title. The Registry keeps the original, and that original is what counts. Once you have the CTC, compare it line by line with the owner’s duplicate you were shown: the title number, the registered owner, the technical description, the area, and every annotation at the back. Only when the two match exactly can you say that the title shown to you is legitimate.

Pay close attention to those annotations. A CTC can show things a seller would rather you not see, such as an existing mortgage, an adverse claim, a notice of lis pendens, or an annotated affidavit of loss. A seller holding an “original” duplicate that was already declared lost should make you stop and ask questions.

While you’re at it, don’t stop at the title. Check that the person selling is really the registered owner, or that whoever claims to act for the owner has a valid Special Power of Attorney. Get a copy of the latest tax declaration and confirm the real property taxes are paid. And visit the property itself. Find out who is actually living there or using it.

The lesson is simple. Original documents are good, but relying on them alone is not. As a buyer, you cannot be passive and take everything at face value. Due diligence is not optional. The law protects a buyer in good faith, but our courts have refused to treat as being in good faith a buyer who ignored warning signs that were there to be checked. If a sale like this ever reaches court, that is exactly what the other side will ask: what did you check, and what did you ignore?

If you’re about to buy a property and want a second set of eyes on the documents, book a consultation and we’ll walk through it with you.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Atty. Marc Bañares

Litigation lawyer focused on land, title and property disputes. Bañares Law, Parañaque.

Next
Next

Tenant Refuses to Receive Your Demand Letter? There’s a Way Around It